Examples of Public Law Cases involving Commercial Regulation
- Electricity Settlements Case (advised the Electricity Settlements Company over the consequences of the overruling by an EU Court in November 2018 of a Commission decision approving a notifiable state aid which has thrown the electricity capacity market into disarray).
- AES Kilroot (advised in a Northern Ireland case involving potential litigation over conditions of withdrawal following unsuccessful auction bid).
- SSE Generation v. Ofgem (National Grid intervening) (successfully resisting a major energy appeal to the Competition and Markets Authority against a decision of Ofgem based on an EU Directive).
- UK Power Networks v Ofgem (successful judicial review on behalf of UK power for unlawfully determining an electricity dispute between UK Power and Wilmott Dixon).
- UK Power v. Ofgem (successful judicial review on behalf of UK Power resulting in quashing of decision on electricity supply by Ofgem).
- Cayman Water Company v. Cayman Water Authority and Another (successful defence on behalf of the Cayman Water Authority in judicial review proceedings before the Cayman Grand Court: the application was dismissed).
- R (Leyton Orient) v. Olympic Park Legacy Company (successful defence on behalf of Olympic Park Legacy Company in judicial review proceedings brought by Leyton Orient of the Company’s procurement exercise for the Olympic Stadium ‘legacy’: the application was dismissed).
- Western Power v. Ofgem (currently representing UK Power as an interested party in judicial review proceedings brought by Western Power against a regulatory decision by Ofgem on the losses incentive mechanism for electricity distribution).
- R (Heathrow Hydrant) v. Heathrow Airport Limited (currently instructed in a judicial review against Heathrow Airport of ground-handling regulations).
- NERL v. DfT (advised the Civil Aviation Authority in respect of a threatened judicial review over pensions calculations by the DfT/CAA).
- Environment Agency v WEEE Light (successful defence of WEEE Light against test case criminal prosecution by the Environment Agency: the case was dismissed in the Crown Court at a preliminary hearing).
- R (Scottish Power) v Electricity Markets Authority (successful defence of National Grid as interested party in a judicial review claim brought by Scottish Power against the regulator).
- R (Rockware Glass) v Chester CC (successful judicial review of grant of environmental discharge consents to rival glass manufacturer: decision quashed).
- R (National GridTransco) v Environment Agency (successful judicial review in a leapfrog appeal to the House of Lords against a regulatory decision of the Environment Agency in respect of successor liability for contaminated land).
- R -v- Financial Services Commissioner ex p. X and Others (acting successfully for the Financial Services Commissioner in Gibraltar on appeal in a judicial review challenge to regulatory disclosure).
- R (Exoteric Gas Solutions) -v- Transco 2003 (acting successfully for Transco on a challenge brought against the Secretary of State relating to alleged monopoly abuse by Transco).
- R -v- Securities and Futures Authority, ex p. Fleurose (successful defence of SFA in a challenge by an arbitrage trader to the fairness of the FSA disciplinary procedures).
- Yukos -v- FSA , London Stock Exchange & Rosneft (successfully resisting on behalf of the London Stock Exchange Yukos’ application for permission to apply for judicial review of. IPO of the Rosneft group of companies )
- Needler Financial Services v. Taber (successfully defending Mr Taber on damages claim in the Chancery Division flowing from building society demutualisation – important test case for the FSA Ombudsman under the then new test case procedure).
Examples of Public Law Cases involving Human Rights and Civil Liberties
- MK v Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (acting in a challenge in Hong Kong to the laws which prohibit same-sex marriage).
- In the Matter of D (major case in the Supreme Court concerning the exercise of parental rights over 16-17 year old children and whether those rights included deprivation of liberty).
- Welsh Ministers v. PJ (Supreme Court case involving the legality of community treatment orders to deprive a patient of their liberty).
- An NHS Trust v. Y (landmark case in the Supreme Court involving the issue of whether pvs patients were liable to be deprived of clinically assisted nutrition and hydration by the agreement of their relatives and the treating clinicians).
- R (Conway) v. Secretary of State for Justice (acted at first instance in major challenge to the assisted dying laws).
- Re Charlie Gard (case about the right to life of a child suffering from a disease which the UK clinicians thought was untreatable but where alternative treatment was offered in the USA),
- P&Q v Surrey CC and P v Cheshire West (successful appearance before the Supreme Court in landmark cases involving deprivation of liberty and incapacity: three rulings of the Court of Appeal in different cases overturned).
- Recovery of Medical Costs for Asbestos Diseases (Wales) Bill (acting for National Assembly of Wales in first reference to the Supreme Court raising issues of compatibility between the Bill and Article 1 Protocol1 ECHR).
- Ubamaka v Secretary for Justice (major victory on point of principle in the Court of Final Appeal in Hong Kong resulting in ruling that those subject to deportation laws are, as far as their core fundamental rights are concerned, protected).
- Norris v. Secretary of State (successful extradition appeal on behalf of Mr Norris raising issues under Article 7 ECHR in establishing the absence of any crime in price fixing pror to the Enterprise Act)
- Belfast CC v Misbehavin’ Limited (successfully acting for Belfast City Council in the House of Lords in a sex establishment licensing appeal raising ECHR issues)
- R (Sacker) -v- HM Coroner for West Yorkshire February (acting successfully for Claimant in appeal before the House of Lords relating to the right to life under Article 2 ECHR).
- Dobson v. Thames Water Utilities Ltd (successful appeal in Human Rights Act damages claims for nuisance: Article 8 ECHR issues)
- G v E (successfully represented the Official Solicitor in a major case in the Court of Appeal involving issues on incapacity and Article 5 ECHR under the Mental Capacity Act 2005)
- TTM v. London Borough of Hackney (successfully acting for a detained patient in an important case in the Court of Appeal involving the relationship between Article 5 ECHR and habeas corpus)
- Wilson -v- First County Trust (successfully acted for a number of insurance companies under the auspices of the Association of British Insurers in major human rights challenge in the House of Lords to commercial consumer legislation).
- R (Munjaz) -v- Secretary of State (successful challenge on behalf of MIND in the House of Lords to seclusion in mental hospitals).
- Peck -v- United Kingdom (successful Strasbourg challenge for breach of privacy under Article 8 ECHR relating to use of CCTV).
- Roche v. UK (successful Strasbourg challenge to ex-serviceman’s inability to claim for damages: breach of Article 8 ECHR).
- Instructed to advise over human rights issues being raised before the Icelandic Courts in respect of the Emergency Legislation over Insolvency.
- HL v UK (successful Strasbourg challenge to detention of incapacitated mental patient: this case laid the foundation of the Mental Capacity Act 2007).
- Glass -v- United Kingdom (acted successfully in a Strasbourg challenge over ‘do not resuscitate' procedures in a UK hospital)
- Roth GMBH -v- Secretary of State for Food, Environment and Rural Affairs (Successful challenge to the S/S ‘clandestines’ policy as being in breach of Article 1 Protocol 1 and Article 6 ECHR)
- R v N&E Devon Health Authority, ex p. Coughlan (successful appearance in the Court of Appeal with landmark judgment on substantive legitimate expectation and the delimitation between health and social care: Article 8 ECHR issues engaged).
Examples of Public Law Cases/Advisory Work in Other Discrete Areas
Energy and Natural resources
- Electricity Settlements Case (advised the Electricity Settlements Company over the consequences of the overruling by an EU Court in November 2018 of a Commission decision approving a notifiable state aid which has thrown the electricity capacity market into disarray).
- AES Kilroot (advised in a Northern Ireland case involving potential litigation over conditions of withdrawal following unsuccessful auction bid).
- SSE Generation v. Ofgem (National Grid intervening) (successfully resisting a major energy appeal to the Competition and Markets Authority against a decision of Ofgem based on an EU Directive).
- UK Power Networks v Ofgem (successful judicial review on behalf of UK power for unlawfully determining an electricity dispute between UK Power and Wilmott Dixon).
- R (Western Power Distribution Ltd.) v. Gas & Electricity Markets Authority (potentially important application for judicial review by Western Power under the Electricity Directive: acting for UK Power as an interested party).
- UK Power v. Ofgem (successful judicial review on behalf of UK Power resulting in quashing of decision on electricity supply by Ofgem).
- Western Power v. Ofgem (currently representing UK Power as an interested party in judicial review proceedings brought by Western Power against a regulatory decision by Ofgem on the losses incentive mechanism for electricity distribution).
- R (Heathrow Hydrant) v. Heathrow Airport Limited (currently instructed in a judicial review against Heathrow Airport of ground-handling regulations).
- R (Scottish Power) v Electricity Markets Authority (successful defence of National Grid as interested party in a judicial review claim brought by Scottish Power against the regulator).
- R (National GridTransco) v Environment Agency (successful judicial review in a leapfrog appeal to the House of Lords against a regulatory decision of the Environment Agency in respect of successor liability for contaminated land).
- R (Exoteric Gas Solutions) -v- Transco 2003 (acting successfully for Transco on a challenge brought against the Secretary of State relating to alleged monopoly abuse by Transco).
- Currently advising UK Power on Price Control Issues
Environment
- R (Plan B Earth and Others) v. Secretary of State for Business Energy and Industrial Strategy (challenge to Secretary of State’s policy on carbon emissions reduction successfully resisted).
- Seiont, Gwyrfai and Llyfni Anglers Society v. Natural Resources Wales (successfully resisted environmental challenge based on an erroneous interpretation of the Environmental Liability Directive).
- Forager Ltd v Natural England (advised on a challenge to environmental civil sanctions).
- Bimini Bay Coalition Limited v Prime Minister of the Bahamas (successful defence of developers in resisting interim injunction in judicial review proceedings in the Privy Council).
- Environment Agency v WEEE (successful defence against test case environmental prosecution).
- Wells v UK (successful environmental challenge before the CJEU on failure to obtain an environmental impact assessment for old mining permissions).
- RSPB v UK (successful environmental challenge before the CJEU for breach of the Birds Directive)
- Hong Kong Link Road Project (Advising in respect of major environmental dredging project in Hong Kong on whether environmental impact assessment is binding as to location of elements of the project).
- Climate Change Opinion for the Climate Change Committee on Carbon Emissions by the UK.
- R (Prokopp) -v- LB of Tower Hamlets (successful defence of challenge to planning decision of LB of Tower Hamlets in respect of the East London Railway Extension).R v North Yorkshire County Council, ex. Brown and Cartwright (successful defence in the House of Lords of quashing of Council decision in the Court of Appeal because of a failure to obtain an environmental impact assessment).
Offshore and Foreign Jurisdictions (including the Strasbourg and Luxembourg Courts)
- MK v Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (acting in a challenge in Hong Kong to the laws which prohibit same-sex marriage).
- STM v Financial Services Commissioner (instructed in a financial services judicial review in Gibraltar).
- Larsen v. Comptroller of Taxes (several appearances in Jersey (being led by a Jersey advocate) in a case involving tax information exchange agreements).
- Ubamaka v Secretary for Justice (major victory on point of principle in the Court of Final Appeal in Hong Kong resulting in ruling that those subject to deportation laws are, as far as their core fundamental rights are concerned, protected).
- Cayman Water Company v. Cayman Water Authority and Another (successful defence on behalf of the Cayman Water Authority in judicial review proceedings before the Cayman Grand Court: the application was dismissed).
- R -v- Financial Services Commissioner ex p. X and Others (acting successfully for the Financial Services Commissioner in the Court of Appeal of Gibraltar on appeal in a judicial review challenge to regulatory disclosure).
- Engaged in advising in cases in Jersey and in Strasbourg on demands made under Tax Information Exchange Agreements (ongoing).
- R (Watts) -v- Secretary of State for Health (successfully challenged NHS waiting lists in the Court of Justice of the EU).
- Wells v UK (successful environmental challenge before the Court of Justice of the European Union on failure to obtain an environmental impact assessment for old mining permissions).
- RSPB v UK (successful environmental challenge before the Court of Justice of the European Union for breach of the Birds Directive)
- Peck -v- United Kingdom (successful Strasbourg challenge for breach of privacy under Article 8 ECHR relating to use of CCTV).
- Roche v. UK (successful Strasbourg challenge to ex-serviceman’s inability to claim for damages: breach of Article 8 ECHR).
- HL v UK (successful Strasbourg challenge to detention of incapacitated mental patient: this case laid the foundation of the Mental Capacity Act 2007).
- Glass -v- United Kingdom (acted successfully in a Strasbourg challenge over ‘do not resuscitate' procedures in a UK hospital)
- Teixeira v London Borough of Lambeth (2010) (success in the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg on right of residence under EU law for parent caring for child of migrant worker)
- Rowse v Secretary for the Civil Service (major judicial review in Hong Kong successfully acting for civil servant disciplined for failing to oversee the budget for the Harborfest – a range of natural justice issues including unlawful delegation, unfair process and failure to allow legal representation: decision quashed)
- Has appeared in three telecommunications judicial review cases in Hong Kong.
- Has appeared in other cases in the Hong Kong Court including before the Court of Final Appeal in a case on the privilege against self incrimination.
- Hong Kong Link Road Project (Advising in respect of major environmental dredging project in Hong Kong on whether environmental impact assessment is binding as to location of elements of the project).
- Advised Hong Kong housing corporation on new IDO - in successful judicial review defence)
Constitutional Law
- Advising a prominent group in Northern Ireland on the compatibility of the Northern Ireland Protocol in the draft EU Withdrawal Agreement with the Belfast Agreement.
- R v Mackinlay (successful intervention by the Electoral Commission in the Supreme Court on the proper interpretation of electoral law).
- R (Good Law Project) v Electoral Commission (represented the Electoral Commission in a judicial review challenge brought to aspects of the Commission’s interpretation of provisions of electoral expenses law).
- Re Confidence and Supply Agreement (advising the Welsh Government on a potential judicial review of aspects of the Confidence and Supply Agreement following the 2017 General Election).
- R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union (successfully appeared for the Government of Wales in landmark challenge to the attempt by the Executive to trigger Article 50 without Parliamentary authority).
- Re Unified Patent Court (advising on behalf of the IP Federation on the consequences of Brexit for the UK’s continued participation in the Unified Patent Court)
- R (Wheeler) v Office of the Prime Minister and Home Secretary (major constitutional EU challenge to the Government’s proposed opt-in to the European Arrest Warrant scheme).
- Re the Rt. Hon Iain Duncan Smith M.P. (acted successfully on behalf of Iain Duncan Smith - former Leader of the Conservative opposition) in the Mawer Inquiry).
- Acted successfully for Lord Rennard over his recent suspension from the Liberal-Democrat Party: the case was eventually dealt with through mediation.
- Acetd as independent legal adviser to the Minister for Justice on fundamental rights.
- Appointed as Special Adviser to the Public Administration Select Committee.
- Advice given over appearances before Select Committees (clients include the BBC, Financial Conduct Authority,Bank, and Comptroller and Auditor-General).
- Acted for the President of Fiji in judicial review challenge to the legality of his appointment of the Prime Minister.
- Advice given to Lord Foster over constitutional issues.
Health and Social Care
- In the Matter of D (major case in the Supreme Court concerning the exercise of parental rights over 16-17 year old children and whether those rights included deprivation of liberty).
- Welsh Ministers v. PJ (Supreme Court case involving the legality of community treatment orders to deprive a patient of their liberty).
- An NHS Trust v. Y (landmark case in the Supreme Court involving the issue of whether pvs patients were liable to be deprived of clinically assisted nutrition and hydration by the agreement of their relatives and the treating clinicians)
- R (Conway) v. Secretary of State for Justice (acted at first instance in major challenge to the assisted dying laws).
- Re Charlie Gard (case about the right to life of a child suffering from a disease which the UK clinicians thought was untreatable but where alternative treatment was offered in the USA),
- R v N&E Devon Health Authority, ex p., Coughlan (successfully acted for Pamela Coughlan in ground breaking case over the borderline between health and social care).
- R (Grogan) v. Bexley NHS Trust (successful post Coughlan claim relating to liability of NHS to fund continuing health care).
- R (Watts) v UK (successful challenge in the EU Court of Justice to the legality of NHS waiting lists)
- Currently instructed in a major judicial review claim in Wales on behalf of 23 local authorities where the liability of all the health authorities and local authorities in Wales is being challenged.
- R (Schofield) v Secretary of State for Health (successful judicial review challenge to GP's pensions restrictions).
- P&Q v Surrey CC and P v Cheshire West (successful appearance before the Supreme Court in landmark cases involving deprivation of liberty and incapacity: three rulings of the Court of Appeal in different cases overturned).
- Barry v Gloucster County Council (major House of Lords case on resource allocation issues over community care provision).
- HL v UK (successful Strasbourg challenge to detention of incapacitated mental patient: this case laid the foundation of the Mental Capacity Act 2007).
- Glass -v- United Kingdom (acted successfully in a Strasbourg challenge over ‘do not resuscitate' procedures in a UK hospital)
- Recovery of Medical Costs for Asbestos Diseases (Wales) Bill (acting for National Assembly of Wales in first reference to the Supreme Court raising issues of compatibility between the Bill and Article 1 Protocol1 ECHR)Major written advice given to the Equality and Human Rights Commission as part of its high profile investigation into the Home Care system in England and Wales
Examples of Public Law Work in Other Areas
- Have advised and/or represented three major energy companies in energy-related matters.
- Instructed successfully for the Olympic Park Legacy Company in both Olympic legacy judicial review cases brought by (respectively) Tottenham Hotspur and Leyton Orient which involved major procurement and state aid issues.
- Acted for Pressbof over the Press Charter in a case which raised important media issues under Article10 ECHR.
- Has advised on the legality of sanctions regulations and appeared in cases before the English Courts involving sanctions.
- Has acted in/advised on a number of cases involving pharma regulation.
- Has acted in a number of extradition judicial review cases including two cases (Mucelli and Norris) in the House of Lords.
- Has acted in cases involving the interplay between public international law and judicial review.
- Acts regularly for and against local authorities.
- Currently acting for major internet corporations over privacy issues.
- Has advised on and acted in a number of telecommunications disputes in the UK and Hong Kong.